Paid links are labeled; your price stays the same. Disclosure →

Judaica Advisor
Open menu

Store reviewFast U.S. shipping

Judaica.city review

Judaica.city is a small New Jersey shop run by its founder, Sarah Shatashvili, who makes many of the products with a few friends. It is a good place for custom or wedding kippot, tefillin bags, challah covers and other simcha pieces when you need them fast: free U.S. shipping over $30 and free 30-day returns.

judaica.city

Visit Judaica.city →Partner link, your price stays the same

Where to buy: our top 3 stores right now

How we rank stores
  1. Editor's choice
    1
    Judaica Web Store
    9.9

    Judaica Web Store

    Books, ritual basics, cosmetics, gifts, holiday stock · Ships from Israel, ships worldwide

  2. 2
    Israel-Catalog
    9.8

    Israel-Catalog

    Israeli-made menorahs, Shabbat and holiday Judaica, tallitot, kippot, mezuzahs · Ships from Israel (U.S. duties included)

  3. This review
    3
    Judaica.city
    9.6

    Judaica.city

    Custom kippahs, tefillin bags, challah & wedding Judaica · Ships from Maplewood, NJ (USPS Priority)

Affiliate links: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Judaica Advisor logo

Written by: Judaica Advisor editorial team

Independent Judaica store comparisons for U.S. shoppers · Editorial standards

At a glance

Judaica Advisor mascotOur take in 10 seconds
Ships from
Maplewood, NJ (USPS Priority)
Known for
Custom kippahs, tefillin bags, challah & wedding Judaica
Best for
Free US shipping over $30
Partner link
Yes, your price stays the same
  • Custom kippot and simcha sets
  • Free U.S. shipping over $30, 30-day returns
  • About 1–2 days handling + 3–4 days USPS Priority

What stands out

  1. 1Ships from Maplewood, NJ by USPS Priority Mail: 1 to 2 days of handling plus 3 to 4 days in transit, about 4 to 6 days in all.
  2. 2Free shipping on orders over $30; below that, the cost is shown at checkout. The store sells to U.S. addresses only.
  3. 3Free returns within 30 days of delivery with a prepaid label, for unused items with tags in the original packaging.

Strengths and trade-offs

Pros

  • Personalized kippot for weddings and bar and bat mitzvahs from a maker, not a reseller
  • U.S. shipping in about a week, with no customs wait
  • Free returns with a prepaid label

Cons

  • Orders cannot be changed or cancelled once confirmed, so check names and dates carefully
  • Narrow range: no menorahs, tallitot, tefillin or books
  • The return policy does not say whether personalized items can be returned; ask info@judaica.city first
Judaica.city

Verdict

9.6 / 10 · Free US shipping over $30

Partner link, your price stays the same. Disclosure

Visit Judaica.city

More store reviews